Gardenia by Kelsey Sutton (ARC Review)

16789354_1649356128701063_4950408957823811584_n1Gardenia by Kelsey Sutton

Release Date: February 28, 2017

*ARC provided for an honest review via Netgalley from Diversion Publishing – thanks so much for sending me a copy!*

Gardenia was one of my most anticipated reads of 2017. It sounded like the coolest concept that I’ve seen in a while in YA mysteries, and I couldn’t wait to get my hands on it. I may have even done a little happy dance when I saw I was approved on Netgalley. While the concept was as cool as I thought it was going to be, there were some major issues I had with it, which saddened this Book Princess.

Once upon a time…

Seventeen-year-old Ivy Erickson has one month, twenty-seven days, four hours, fifty-nine minutes, and two seconds to live.

Ever since she was a child, Ivy has been able to see countdown clocks over everyone’s heads indicating how long before they will die. She can’t do anything about anyone elseโ€™s, nor can she do anything about her own, which will hit the zero hour before she even graduates high school.

A life cut short is tragic, but Ivy does her best to make the most of it. She struggles emotionally with her deep love for on-again, off-again boyfriend Myers Patripski. She struggles financially, working outside of school to help her mom and her sister. And she struggles to cope with the murder of her best friend, another life she couldn’t save. Vanessa Donovan was killed in the woods, and everyone in town believes Ivy had something to do with it.

Then more girls start disappearing. Ivy tries to put her own life in order as she pieces together the truth of who ended Vanessa’s. To save lives and for her own sanity.

The clock is always ticking. And Ivy’s only hope is to expose the truth before it runs out completely.

Before we talk about anything else, let’s just fangirl a bit over this concept. A main character seeing expiration numbers over a person’s head is really nothing new. I’ve seen a few scifi movies with this concept, but this was the first time that I saw it in a YA book, and I was pumped. And rightly so, because Sutton created a super cool murder mystery plot with it and I was hooked, trying to figure out who the killer was. Sutton had me guessing pretty much until the big reveal, and Ivy seeing the numbers made it full of tension and confusion. Sutton created an absolutely amazing plot for this story and I loved it.

However, there were a few issues along the way. At some points, I thought the plot was dragged out too long. There were points that Ivy needed to get to, but it just took wayyyyy too long to get there. There was a number counting down, but I felt the author rushed some parts earlier into that countdown and not enough at the end. That led me to just swipe through the pages to get to that countdown just so I could hit that climax of the plot and the grand finale of the countdown. I think if it was a bit more spaced out, it would have kept and held my attention better.

It was also interesting how Ivy approached her time power. I kept thinking, why isn’t she using it more? Why isn’t she out telling people? Using it to truly solve the mystery? But then it came to me: who would believe it? Would I believe Ivy if she told me that? I kind of loved how Sutton actually made it so realistic. Ivy had this power, but she was stuck in a society that wouldn’t and couldn’t let her use it. It was interesting to think about that and it definitely added to the story for me although I did wish Ivy used it a bit more.

Beauty and the…beastly numbers? Eh, it was worth a shot.

The romance in the story was…okay, Myles and Ivy were a mess. I totally shipped them, but these two…oh goodness, I’m not sure what to do with them. I really don’t understand how Myles stuck around, and it felt a bit unrealistic to me. However, again, I did ship these messy two, so I’m not sure what to do with that either.

Ivy, herself, was an interesting narrator. I didn’t love her completely, but she was good enough. I suppose I never really connected with her, but as I said, I liked her enough to root for a good ending for her.

Overall, this book didn’t live up to my high expectations for it, but I did enjoy it overall. I thought it was interesting and a super cool addition to YA mysteries. Sutton did a great job flushing out her concept, but there were a few issues in the execution of other things. It was definitely an interesting read, but I’m not sure how much I would recommend. 3 crowns for this book, and a Belle rating!


Check it out:

What do you think? Have any of your most anticipated reads of 2017 fallen flat for you? Can you love a concept of a book and not love the execution and what boys have done this to you? Let’s discuss in the comments below!


6 thoughts on “Gardenia by Kelsey Sutton (ARC Review)

  1. Great review, Mandy! I thought this concept in a YA novel was awesome but admittedly was afraid of what the author would do with it. The potential is definitely there but will it deliver? I’ve had that happen way too many times… I don’t remember what my last disappointments were but that’s probably for the best >.>
    Also, I’m not sure about that relationship between the MC and her boyfriend… Was it necessary? Does it add anything to the story but more drama? You say you ship them, though, so I guess it was a smart move on the author’s part to include it hahaha (I will probably ship them too, I always ship the problematic couples… What would Freud say to this?)
    Anyway, I’m quite curious about who the killer is, now! And what happens in the end! I’m glad you didn’t include any spoilers ^^


    1. Yeah, I’m not sure it really delivered. I had such high expectations but I thinkthe author got a little lost in the execution and it just fell apart. There was some really good parts but it just…it felt like too much?
      And yeah, the romance was super unnecessary and there was a point though where it was the only thing going though since it did dwindle. So I think that’s why I did ship them? They were suchhhhh a mess though that it drove me insane. It could have easily done without. But lol I’m sure Freud would be proud and excited? XD
      It did have an ending I wasnt expecting so it did kind of come back at the end! It was an interesting read so it might be worthwhile!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This book does sound like it has such amazing potential. I’m bummed it didn’t quite live up to your expectations. I am reading it this weekend though. I am looking forward to the good parts of the romance and mystery that you mentioned. ๐Ÿ™‚


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s